Crate & Rotate: Managing Dogs That Don’t Get Along

We all want our dogs to live together peacefully—playing, snuggling, sharing toys like the perfect Instagram pack. But the truth is, some dogs are best separated, regardless of training. The risk of an incident occurring is not worth the reward of a few moments of potential peaceful coexistence.

At Chomps Dog Training, we work with clients every day whose dogs have an extensive fighting history. In their case, despite training, clients may not feel comfortable having both dogs out at the same time. The good news? There is a solution that doesn’t involve rehoming—and it’s called Crate & Rotate.

What is Crate & Rotate?

Crate & Rotate is a structured management system where dogs that don’t get along are kept separate using crates, gates, or closed doors, and rotated between free time and confinement. It’s a safe way to give each dog quality time without putting them in situations that lead to fights or chronic stress.

It’s not punishment. It’s management. And it works.

Who Is Crate & Rotate For?

• Dogs with a history of fighting
• Dogs that don’t respect each other’s space
• Dogs with very different energy levels or personalities
• New dogs who haven’t earned full access yet
• Homes where leadership and structure are still being established

If your dogs can’t be trusted together without supervision, or if you find yourself constantly tense trying to “keep the peace”, this method is for you.

Common Mistakes That Lead to Dog Fights

Before we talk solutions, here are a few patterns we often see in households where dogs clash:

• Free-roaming all day with no supervision
• Sharing high-value items like food, bones, or toys
• No clear structure or obedience training
• Correcting one dog while letting the other do whatever they want
• Ignoring subtle signs of tension (like staring, stalking, blocking, or stiff postures)

These situations allow pressure to build until a fight breaks out. And once dogs fight, the relationship often changes permanently.

How to Implement Crate & Rotate

1. Set Up Safe Spaces. Use crates, gates, separate rooms, or exercise pens to give each dog a “home base” where they can decompress without pressure.
2. Create a Rotation Schedule. Rotate dogs in and out of free time. While one is out, the other rests. Then switch. Both get attention, structure, and movement—without being forced into a stressful interaction.
3. Train During Rotations. Use this time to work on obedience, leash manners, place work, and impulse control. Build respect and structure separately before expecting coexistence.
4. Supervise All Interaction (If Any). If your long-term goal is peaceful cohabitation, start with short, structured, on-leash sessions. But if your dogs have a serious history of conflict, coexistence may never be safe—and that’s okay. Management is a valid, responsible choice.
5. Stay Consistent. Crate & Rotate is not a temporary fix. It’s a lifestyle adjustment that gives dogs the structure they need—and gives you peace of mind.

What Crate & Rotate is NOT

• A sign of failure
• A punishment
• A forever prison sentence
• Cruel or isolating

When done properly, dogs thrive with structure. They rest better. They learn better. And they stop living in constant tension with one another.

Final Thoughts: Not Every Dog Needs a Best Friend

The idea that all dogs should live together in harmony 24/7 is just that—an idea. Real life looks different. And sometimes, the most loving thing you can do for your dogs is give them space and structure.

If you’re struggling with inter-dog aggression or tension in your home, don’t wait until the next fight. Our board and train programs help reset behavior, create structure, and teach you how to lead confidently, even in a multi-dog home.

‍